Welcome to Accurate Plumbing Services

Toilet Repair or Replace: Deciding for Faulty Toilets

Professional Toilet Repair Service.

When it comes to household issues, a faulty toilet can quickly turn into a messy and inconvenient problem. It’s a situation no one wants to deal with, but sooner or later, most homeowners face the dilemma of toilet repair or replace their malfunctioning toilet. In this article, we will guide you through this decision-making process, helping you make an informed choice that saves you both time and money.

Understanding the Common Toilet Repair Problems

Identifying Leaks and Drips

One of the first signs of a faulty toilet is often a pesky leak. Whether it’s a slow, consistent drip or a sudden puddle around the base, leaks should not be ignored. They not only waste water but can also lead to costly damage to your flooring and subfloor.

Frequent Clogging Issues

Another common problem is frequent clogging. If you find yourself reaching for the plunger more often than you’d like, your toilet might have an underlying issue. Clogs can result from a variety of factors, including mineral buildup, blockages in the pipes, or a low-flow toilet.

Running Water and High Water Bills

If you hear your toilet constantly running or notice a spike in your water bills, it’s time to investigate. Running water indicates a problem with the flushing mechanism, while a higher water bill suggests water is being wasted.

Assessing the Age of Your Toilet Repair

Lifespan of Different Toilet Types

Toilets aren’t immortal; they have a finite lifespan. The longevity of your toilet depends on factors such as the quality of the materials used and how well it’s maintained. Most toilets last between 10 to 15 years.

Signs of Wear and Tear

As your toilet ages, it may show signs of wear and tear. Cracks in the porcelain, rust on the tank or bolts, or loose fittings are all indicators that your toilet might be nearing the end of its life.

The Cost Factor

Estimating Toilet Repair Costs

Before deciding whether to repair or replace your toilet, you need to consider the cost of repairs. Minor issues like a flapper replacement or valve adjustment are relatively inexpensive. However, major repairs, such as fixing a cracked bowl or replacing the entire flushing mechanism, can add up quickly.

Budgeting for a New Toilet 

On the other hand, purchasing a new toilet comes with its own cost. You’ll need to budget not only for the toilet itself but also for installation, which may require the expertise of a professional plumber.

Environmental Impact

Water Efficiency and Conservation

In today’s eco-conscious world, it’s essential to consider the environmental impact of your choices. Older toilets can be significant water-wasters, using up to 7 gallons per flush. Newer, water-efficient models use as little as 1.28 gallons per flush, contributing to water conservation efforts.

Eco-Friendly Toilet Repair Options

If you’re environmentally conscious, you might opt for eco-friendly toilet options like dual-flush toilets, which allow you to choose between a low and high water volume for flushing, further reducing water usage.

Aesthetic and Functional Considerations

Modern vs. Traditional Styles

The aesthetics of your bathroom can be a deciding factor. Modern toilets come in sleek designs with clean lines, while traditional toilets have a classic, timeless look. Your choice should complement your bathroom’s overall style.

Accessibility and Comfort

Consider the comfort and accessibility of your toilet. If you have elderly family members or individuals with mobility issues, a comfort-height toilet with accessible features may be the better choice.

DIY vs. Professional Repair

When Can You DIY?

For minor issues like a running toilet or a loose handle, a confident DIYer may be able to make the necessary repairs. Many hardware stores offer DIY toilet repair kits for common problems.

Benefits of Hiring a Professional

However, for complex issues or if you’re unsure about the problem, it’s wise to consult a professional plumber. They have the experience and expertise to diagnose and fix problems correctly, preventing future headaches.

Choosing a New Toilet

Types of Toilets

When selecting a new toilet, you’ll encounter various types, including:

  • Two-Piece Toilets: These are the most common and typically the most affordable.
  • One-Piece Toilets: Sleek and easy to clean, these toilets are a popular choice.
  • Wall-Mounted Toilets: Ideal for saving space and creating a modern look.
  • Corner Toilets: Perfect for tight spaces or small bathrooms.

Features to Consider

Toilets come with an array of features, such as:

  • Dual Flush: Allows you to choose between a light flush for liquid waste and a heavy flush for solid waste.
  • Slow-Close Seats: Prevents noisy slamming and accidental pinched fingers.
  • Powerful Flush: Ensures efficient waste removal with less water usage.

The Importance of Proper Installation

Avoiding Future Problems

Regardless of whether you repair or replace your toilet, proper installation is crucial. An improperly installed toilet can lead to leaks, wobbling, and other issues down the line.

Hiring a Certified Plumber

To ensure your toilet is installed correctly, it’s often best to hire a certified plumber. They have the knowledge and tools to secure a watertight seal and prevent future complications.

Maintenance Tips for a Toilet Repair

Regular Cleaning

Keeping your toilet clean not only maintains its appearance but also prevents home repair stains and odors. Use a non-abrasive cleaner and a soft brush to avoid damaging the porcelain.

Simple Checks and Fixes

Perform routine checks for loose bolts, worn-out flappers, and other common issues. Addressing these problems early can prevent more extensive and costly repairs.

The Decision-Making Process Of Toilet Repair

Weighing the Pros and Cons of Toilet Repair

In the end, the decision to repair or replace your toilet should be based on a careful evaluation of the pros and cons. Consider factors like the age of your toilet, the cost of repairs, and your long-term goals for water conservation and bathroom aesthetics.

Getting Multiple Opinions

If you’re unsure about the best course of action, don’t hesitate to seek multiple opinions. Consult plumbers or home improvement experts who can provide personalized advice based on your specific situation.

When it comes to making the right decision for your faulty toilet, Accurate Plumbing Services is here to help. Our team of experienced plumbers can assess your toilet’s condition and provide expert recommendations. Whether you need a simple repair or a toilet replacement, we’ve got you covered. Contact us today for a free consultation.


In the battle between repairing and replacing your faulty toilet, the right choice ultimately depends on your unique circumstances. Take into account the age and condition of your toilet, your budget, and your environmental concerns. With careful consideration and, if needed, the expertise of a professional plumber, you can enjoy a trouble-free toilet for years to come.


Q1: Can I repair a leaky toilet myself?

Yes, some minor leaks can be fixed with basic DIY skills and tools. However, for complex leaks or if you’re unsure, it’s best to consult a professional plumber.

Q2: How long does a typical toilet last?

The lifespan of a toilet varies depending on usage and maintenance. On average, a well-maintained toilet can last 10-15 years.

Q3: Are eco-friendly toilets worth the investment?

Yes, they can significantly reduce water consumption and lower your utility bills over time, making them a wise long-term investment.

Q4: What’s the average cost of toilet repair or replacement?

The cost varies depending on the type and features of the toilet you choose. On average, expect to pay between $200 and $700 for the toilet itself, plus installation costs.

Q5: How can I prevent clogs of toilet repair?

Regular maintenance, proper flushing habits, and avoiding flushing non-flushable items can help prevent home repiping from clogs.